Comparing Israel to Iran

Iran has a much larger land area of 1,648,195 km² compared to Israel’s 22,070 km². Iran also has a significantly larger population of 88,551,000 compared to Israel’s 9,558,000.1In terms of technology and economic development, Israel is more advanced. Israel has a higher GDP per capita of $55,140 compared to Iran’s $3,980.1 Israel is also considered a technologically advanced society, ranking 19th in the UN’s Human Development Index, while Iran ranks around 70th.4The search results also indicate that Iran has a mixed economy, while Israel has a liberal market economy. Iran has higher inflation at 43.49% compared to Israel’s 4.39%, and a higher unemployment rate of 11% versus Israel’s 3.5%.1In summary, Iran is a much larger country in terms of land area and population, but Israel is more technologically and economically developed, with a higher GDP per capita and standard of living.

the key reasons for the economic poverty and high inflation in Iran compared to Israel are:

Sanctions and international isolation: The search results indicate that Iran has faced extensive international sanctions, which have crippled its economy and contributed to rising poverty and inflation. The “lost decade” of economic growth due to sanctions and volatile oil prices has pushed nearly 10 million Iranians into poverty.
Mismanagement and inefficient governance: The search results suggest that the “inefficiency of successive clerical governments” in Iran, as well as “bad economic management”, have hindered the country’s economic development and exacerbated poverty. This is in contrast to Israel’s more liberal market economy.
High inflation and currency depreciation: Iran is experiencing very high inflation, with the official rate at 47.5% and predictions it could reach 55-60%. This has led to a massive devaluation of the Iranian currency, with the rial trading at over 600,000 to the US dollar on the free market.5 This has severely eroded the purchasing power of Iranians.
Fiscal deficits and money supply growth: The search results indicate that fiscal deficits and rapid growth in the money supply are driving inflation in Iran, which in turn is contributing to rising poverty.3 Controlling these factors will be crucial to curbing inflation.

Iran has been grappling with international sanctions for various reasons. Let’s delve into this topic in-depth:

Nuclear Program and Treaty Violations:
- Iran’s clandestine nuclear program has been a major point of contention. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and major powers assert that Iran’s nuclear activities violate its treaty obligations.
- When Iran joined the Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT) in 1967, it pledged not to become a nuclear-armed state. However, its actions raised concerns, leading to sanctions.
Stringent Sanctions:
- The sanctions imposed on Iran are among the most stringent globally. They cover various sectors, entities, and individuals.
- These sanctions are layered and relate to nuclear proliferation, terrorism, and human rights issues
Iran’s Support for Terrorist Organizations:
- Tehran has been providing military and financial support to terrorist groups like Hamas and Lebanese Hezbollah.
- Despite heavy sanctions, Iran continues to allocate over $700 million annually to support these groups, including up to $100 million annually to Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist organizations.
- Iran has also transferred artillery rockets and facilitated the local production of rockets and missiles for Palestinian groups.
- The sophistication of Hamas’s attacks on Israel has drawn attention to Iran’s backing of terrorist activities in the Middle East
Evasion and Circumvention:
- Iran evades sanctions through channels like the United Arab Emirates (UAE), which has become a haven for sanctions evasion.
- The UAE, despite being gray-listed by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), plays a role in facilitating financial transactions that bypass sanctions.
- Additionally, UN restrictions on Iran’s trade of missile-related technology have expired, allowing more freedom in moving ballistic missile components ³.
Iran’s Role in Russia-Ukraine Conflict:
- Iran supplies Shahed-136 unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to Russia for its war with Ukraine.
- Despite multiple rounds of designations targeting Iran’s UAV program, Iranian drones remain a key tool in Russia’s hands.
- Iran manages to advance both Hamas’s goals in Israel and Russia’s objectives in Ukraine while facing sanctions and international scrutiny ³.

In summary, Iran’s actions, including its nuclear program, support for terrorist groups, and involvement in regional conflicts, have led to extensive international sanctions. These measures aim to curb Iran’s behavior and address global security concerns.

Learn more

Israel is widely believed to possess nuclear weapons. Estimates of Israel’s stockpile range between 80 and 400 nuclear warheads. The country is believed to have the ability to deliver these warheads through various methods, including:

Aircraft
Submarine-launched cruise missiles
The Jericho series of intermediate to intercontinental range ballistic missiles ¹.

Israel’s first deliverable nuclear weapon is thought to have been completed in late 1966 or early 1967, making it the sixth country in the world to develop such weapons. However, Israel maintains a policy of deliberate ambiguity, neither officially denying nor admitting to having nuclear weapons. Instead, it consistently states that “Israel will not be the first country to introduce nuclear weapons to the Middle East” ¹.

Despite international pressure, Israel has not signed the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT), citing national security interests. Additionally, Israel has developed the Begin Doctrine, which involves counter-proliferation and preventive strikes to prevent other regional actors from acquiring nuclear weapons. Notably, Israel conducted Operation Opera and Operation Orchard, destroying nuclear reactors in Iraq and Syria, respectively. The Stuxnet malware, which severely damaged Iranian nuclear facilities in 2010, is also believed to have been developed jointly by the United States and Israel. As of 2019, Israel remains the only country in the Middle East believed to possess nuclear weapons ¹.

This complex situation underscores the delicate balance between deterrence, security, and regional stability in the context of nuclear capabilities.

In summary, the combination of international sanctions, economic mismanagement, high inflation, and currency depreciation have been the primary drivers of the economic crisis and widespread poverty in Iran, in contrast to the more stable and developed economy of Israel. Addressing these structural issues will be critical for Iran to improve its economic conditions.